facebook
twitter
pinterest
expert@trans-siberian.co.uk UK: +44 (0)345 521 2910 USA: 1 8665 224308
  • Journeys
    • Trans-Siberian Classic
      • Journey Planning Guide
      • Trans-Siberian Classic – departing St. Petersburg
      • Trans-Siberian Classic – departing Moscow
      • Trans-Siberian Classic – departing Beijing
      • Trans-Siberian Classic – departing Vladivostok
    • Trans-Siberian Rail Cruises
    • Luxury Trans-Siberian Rail Cruises
    • China Trips
  • Destinations
    • Russia
      • Ekaterinburg
      • Irkutsk & Lake Baikal
      • Moscow
      • Novosibirsk
      • Perm
      • St Petersburg
      • Ulan-Uday & Buryatia
      • Vladivostok
    • Mongolia
      • Bayan-Gobi
      • Elstei
      • Erlian
      • Huhehot
      • Naadam Festival
      • Terelj National Park
    • China
      • Beijing
      • Guangzhou
      • Guilin
      • Harbin
      • Hong Kong
    • Interactive Map
  • Expert Help
    • About
      • No Ordinary Travel Company
      • Our People
      • Our Small Print
    • Responsible Travel
    • Flights
    • Visa Info
    • Trains to Russia
    • Life on board Classic Trans-Siberian
    • Traveller’s Checklist
    • Booking
    • FAQ
    • Hints & Tips
  • Gallery
  • Blog
  • Contact

Blog Post

This word “Defective”#1

24 Apr 2020
Comment are off
Bernard H. Wood
disability

“Some people avoid them, ignore them, or pretend they don’t exist. Ìt makes them feel uncomfortable and they have an ‘animal instinct’ to avoid people with such problems.”

I am having a sobering conversation with ‘A’ about the plight of people living with disabilities in Russia. She should know, for she has challenges of her own that have caused such medieval responses from outsiders – and insiders too.

Officially, the system has caught up with the problem and has dedicated premises, workers, budget, and facilities to provide much needed care. It’s all “on paper” as ‘A’ puts it, though in her experience, the transference of these wonders into living reality leaves much to be desired.

“In law there are a lot of possibilities and care opportunities. In reality it’s so difficult to get the most needed help. Request help and nothing happens.

The organisations take money from the state budget but give very little help. They are not as productive or helpful as they should be.”

Litany

Naturally, I am curious to hear an explanation as to why such a situation exists. I run through a list of possible defects within a given system, and ‘A’ confirms them all.

The intertwining litany covers glacial bureaucracy, ineffective assessment, lack of funds and low wages, extended waiting times, unproductive, or unmotivated staff, unprofessionalism and more.

“It’s very rare that someone is helped,” she tells me. “It’s more exceptional than normal. They are badly organised, with too many people (to assist) and a limited budget. They are not equipped to deal with the problem.”

Angloinfo is more succinct in describing the prevailing situation, but it amounts to much the same:-

“Provision for the disabled in Russia is poor and dated compared to most advanced countries … this is… starting to be addressed by the government …attitudes of people in general are still far from supportive or helpful, and it will take some time before access and acceptance are on a par with Western countries.”

After reading account after account, purportedly from Russians living with disabilities; the news is largely grim and often appalling. There are a few positive accounts of achievement in the face of adversity, but not nearly enough.

Attitudes

I have to translate the unfamiliar Russian word that ‘A’ uses to describe the way those with disabilities are often regarded by the public at large.

With some degree of disgust I see “defective” and “incomplete” staring back at me from the translator screen, as if a person with difficulties is somehow less than a full person, and is to be dismissed as a result. ‘A’ has found that such an attitude can be present even within a family group: a reason for relatives to remain distant when closer bonding and extra assistance would logically be called for.

I have to ask if such a mindset is a Communist left-over, from when everyone was expected to work with the state to build the promised Soviet Utopia. Those that wouldn’t were a liability to be removed or “re-educated”, and those that couldn’t were an unwelcome burden. ‘A’ agrees that there is some truth to this hypothesis but, frankly; it’s complicated. “It was also there before,” she tells me.

Unfamiliarity breeds

For a start, the “access” infrastructure that we in the West take for granted just isn’t implemented to the same degree within Russia, bizarrely it’s still “early days” for such programs. Such an omission is still felt at all stations of life, from the (mainstream) work place down to colleges and schools.

As a result the default policy, official or not- amounts to exclusion, or segregation by default. Disabled individuals may often be excluded from the “normal” life/education/work that others take for granted, thereby widening the gap between them and the able bodied. How can a society understand, accept or care about those whom it does not know?

Dubious benefits

For many with problems the default situation is a life spent largely at home with varying degrees of  dependency upon family and state provisions. Contrary to what many would assume in the west; there are “pensions” and domestic help available in Russia, but such provisions are relatively modest; falling short in comparison to those that we take for granted.

Disability -and therefore assistance- is graded according to category: 1 to 3, with 1 being the most severe. Even with the worst limitations (deserving of the most help), personal care still falls short, with washing, dressing and toilet needs falling to family members, friends, and even charitable neighbours. Official assistance from social workers is useful when obtained, but usually limited to errands, shopping, cleaning when something more drastic is called for.

There is even financial provision to allow the hiring of external help, paid for by the government. Again though,  the reality of the situation is at odds with the stated intention. The monthly wage is low and beneficiaries often decline the practice – fearing the calibre of individual that such meagre rewards may attract.

Next post

About the Author

Social Share

  • google-share
Ready to Book? Speak to an Expert
Feefo logo

Travellers Checklist

Visa Info » Flights » Trains to Russia » The Checklist »

Hints, Tips & Fun Facts...

Don’t take a suitcase. Take a soft bag with wheels and a pulling handle.
2018 certificate of excellence tripadvisor

Your payment is protected: everything is held in a trust account until you've completed your trip.

Explore the blog

  • Celebrations and Events
  • ►Destinations
    • China
    • Hong Kong
    • Mongolia
    • Moscow
    • Russia
    • St Petersburg
  • ▼Life
    • ►Arts & Culture
      • Food and Drink
      • Stories – Folklore -Superstition
    • History
    • Life in Russia
  • News
  • Russian Language
  • ▼Series
    • (Moderately) Superstitious
    • A and L in Irkutsk
    • A Few Choice Words
    • Alien Visitors
    • All About The Bottom Line
    • All In The Game
    • All In The Preparation
    • All Quiet on the Eastern Front
    • Almost Medieval
    • Ancient Traces Revisited
    • Animated Russia
    • Anomalous Zones
    • Arrival: Beijing
    • Baba Yaga Revisited
    • Backwards and Forwards
    • Baikal at Last!
    • Business in the City of Extremes
    • By the time you read this
    • Captured Fragments
    • Chasing the spirit
    • Cheaper – Better – Easier
    • Christmas Leftovers
    • Doomed Utopias
    • Dreams Made Concrete
    • Easter Variations
    • Eastwards To Novosibirsk
    • Feline Exhibits
    • Fragmentary Views
    • Free Knowledge for the Proletariat
    • Free Russian Cinema
    • Gobi and Steppe Wanderings
    • Good Advices
    • Good Traditions
    • Grandfather Frost
    • Here Seeking Knowledge
    • Hiking – Cooking – Tick Picking
    • How Cold?
    • How Hot?
    • Igor the Shaman
    • In and Out of Ulaanbaatar
    • In and Out of Ulan Uday
    • International Womens Day in Russia
    • Irkutsk Now
    • Is It Safe?
    • Joanna Lumley’s Trans-Siberian Adventure
    • Kizhi: Scattered Memories
    • Kvas – The Good Stuff
    • Language and literature 2016
    • Last stop: Vladivostok
    • Life On Rails
    • Loveless
    • Low Season Traveler
    • March Of The Immortals
    • Maslenitsa
    • Matilda: A Russian Scandal
    • Minefields of the soul #1
    • Mongolia By Proxy
    • More on Krasnoyarsk
    • Mythological?
    • Nightmare Fuel
    • Non-Verbal Confusion
    • Opposing Worlds
    • Over The Border
    • Pagans On Ice
    • Pronunciations and Tribulations
    • Random Freezings
    • Remembrance Day
    • Russia Sells Alaska
    • Russian Language: Ways and Means
    • Russian things to see and do
    • Scam-Tastic
    • Scrapbooks and Backpacks
    • Sculpting the National Character
    • See You In The Bunker
    • Shadow Man in Circumspect
    • Shot By Both Sides
    • Siege Fatigue
    • Something about Cossacks
    • Sort Your Life Out
    • Stretching the Ruble
    • Survivalist
    • Sweeping generalisations
    • Systems of Control
    • Taking Care
    • The Bear Thing -and Other Interlopers
    • The Ghost at Your Shoulder
    • The Other 10%
    • The roll of the egg
    • The Silent Anniversary
    • The Snow Maiden
    • The Spirits of Winter
    • The Temple at the Border
    • There’s a Russian in my House
    • These Four Walls
    • Thespian Pursuits
    • This Word “Defective”
    • Trans-Siberian Offshoots
    • Trips and Tales
    • Unknown Territories
    • Unseen Unheard
    • Visitations
    • Vodka
    • Voices of Experience
    • Welcome to Magnitogorsk
    • When a lobster whistles on top of a mountain
    • Words are Hard
    • X-rays and space ships
    • Yes They Mean Us
    • Your Cash In St.Petersburg Now!
    • Zaryadye Park
  • Tourist Tips
  • Uncategorized

Quick Links

Ready to Book
Speak to an Expert
FAQs

Destinations

Russia
Mongolia
China
Interactive Map

Journeys

Trans-Siberian Classic
Trans-Siberian Rail Cruise
Luxury Trans-Siberian Rail Cruise
China Trips

Contact Us

E: expert@trans-siberian.co.uk
T: +44 (0)345 521 2910

facebook twitter
© 2018 Russia Experience - All rights reserved